Franklin Asian Equity Fund - Direct - Growth vs quant Manufacturing Fund - Growth Option - Direct Plan

TopFund Analysis

The quant Manufacturing Fund - Growth Option - Direct Plan appears stronger based on its higher star rating of 4 and a significantly lower expense ratio of 0.06% compared to Franklin Asian Equity Fund's 0.31%. While Franklin Asian Equity Fund offers better short-term returns with 1Y and 3Y CAGR at 18.09% and 19.49% respectively, the quant Manufacturing Fund excels in long-term performance with a remarkable 5Y CAGR of 24.68%. Investors should consider that while Franklin shows higher returns in the short term, quant's lower expense ratio and better long-term growth potential may provide a more favorable risk-reward balance. For those choosing between the two, the quant Manufacturing Fund may be more appealing for long-term investment despite its lower short-term returns.