Edelweiss Silver ETF vs SBI COMMA Fund - DIRECT PLAN - Growth — which has given better returns?

Edelweiss Silver ETF has a 1-year return of 15.81% versus SBI COMMA Fund - DIRECT PLAN - Growth's 18.49%. Compare NAV, expense ratio and star rating above before deciding, and check consistency over 3-5 years rather than a single year.

Which has the lower expense ratio, Edelweiss Silver ETF or SBI COMMA Fund - DIRECT PLAN - Growth?

Edelweiss Silver ETF's expense ratio is 0.2% versus SBI COMMA Fund - DIRECT PLAN - Growth's 0.25%. A lower expense ratio directly improves your net returns over the long term, all else being equal.

Can I invest in both Edelweiss Silver ETF and SBI COMMA Fund - DIRECT PLAN - Growth?

Yes, but check for portfolio overlap first if both funds are in the same category — holding two funds with very similar underlying stocks reduces the diversification benefit of investing in more than one fund.

Edelweiss Silver ETF vs SBI COMMA Fund - DIRECT PLAN - Growth

Side-by-side comparison of NAV, returns, expense ratio and star rating.

Edelweiss Silver ETF

Edelweiss Mutual Fund

★★★★★

Commodities · Gold

SBI COMMA Fund - DIRECT PLAN - Growth

SBI Mutual Fund

★★★★★

Commodities · Gold

Metric	Edelweiss Silver ETF	SBI COMMA Fund - DIREC...
NAV	₹31.95	₹42.88
Star Rating	★★	★★★★
Expense Ratio	0.2%	0.25%
AUM	₹3,203 Cr	₹17,422 Cr
1M Return	-6.19%	-4.43%
3M Return	-0.27%	-5.25%
6M Return	-10.13%	-6.54%
1Y Return	+15.81%	+18.49%
3Y CAGR	+38.59%	+31.5%
5Y CAGR	—	+23.62%
Risk Level	—	—
Fund Manager	Bhavesh Jain	Raviprakash Sharma

View Fund A View Fund B

Compare More Funds SIP Calculator SIP vs Lumpsum Guide ELSS Tax Saving Funds