The real worry for Indian metal stocks isn't FPI selling. It's more earnings downgrades.

This is a Mint Premium article gifted to you.Subscribe to enjoy similar stories.

Foreign investors pulled $961 million (approximately ₹9,201.14 crore) from India's metals and mining stocks in June, the biggest monthly outflow since August 2023's $1,266 million, according to data from National Securities Depository Ltd, as global investors retreated from cyclical commodities. While the selling appears driven more by portfolio rebalancing than a structural retreat, analysts say the bigger concern is that earnings estimates for the sector may still have further to fall.

Global investors have been cutting exposure to cyclical commodities as uncertainty over global growth, US trade policies, China's demand outlook and a stronger US dollar clouds the sector's outlook. Given their highly cyclical and volatile nature, metal stocks are often among the first to see foreign money head for the exits during periods of heightened risk aversion, market participants said.

The selling also comes after the Nifty Metal index gained more than 13% so far this year, shifting investor focus from the sector's rally to whether earnings can keep pace.

The June outflow reversed almost 79% of January's ₹11,526 crore inflow, according to Karthick Jonagadla, smallcase manager and managing director and chief executive of Quantace Research, who said it was “too large to dismiss as noise but not enough to call a structural exit”.

According to Jonagadla, the real risk is not an earnings collapse, “but that positive growth no longer produces upgrades”.

He said the tactical element reflects a crowded-position reset amid broader macro de-risking, while the fundamental element is a higher earnings-quality hurdle as coking coal, energy, freight and currency pressures challenge margin retention.

The market still expects the Q1FY27 metals universe to deliver 20% revenue growth, 26% Ebitda increase, and 22% net profit growth year-on-year, he said. That suggests share prices have corrected faster than near-term earnings, but the downgrade cycle is not over.

“FY27 Ebitda estimates have already been cut by 6% for Tata Steel, 5% for SAIL and 2% for JSW Steel,” he said.

Ferrous producers look relatively better supported by domestic pricing and spreads, while globally linked non-ferrous names remain more vulnerable to commodity-price reversals. The real entry signal, according to Jonagadla, is sustained margin resilience and stable guidance, and not simply a lower multiple.

“For metals exposure today, I would use a four-part barbell: 45-50% in integrated domestic steel, 25-30% in primary non-ferrous producers, 10-15% in gold and silver exposure, and around 10% in selective downstream names with demonstrable pricing power. Ferrous offers the stronger near-term earnings floor, with Indian steel demand expected to grow 9-10% in FY2027, while non-ferrous provides structural upside through domestic demand growth of 7-9.5%,” added Jonagadla.

In a report released last week, Equirus Securities said India's ferrous sector outperformed between December 2025 and April 2026 on expectations of lower Chinese steel production, fewer exports from China and a sharp recovery in domestic steel profitability. However, after the January-April rally, steel prices have cooled while raw material and operating costs remain elevated.

“Although steel stocks have corrected over the past two months, we believe downside risks to both volumes and profitability persist, with FY27E earnings downgrades likely over the next three quarters.”

On the non-ferrous side, Equirus said a sharp correction in aluminium prices on the London Metal Exchange, coupled with faster West Asia capacity restarts and fresh Indonesian supply, could keep prices range-bound and raise the risk of FY27-28 earnings cuts.

Equirus continues to prefer iron ore miners over steel producers, with Lloyds Metals and Energy remaining its top pick. Within steel, its preference order is Jindal Steel & Power, followed by JSW St...